Minnesota Supreme Court Criminal Blog

Who wouldn't want to read that?

2009-10 Case Roster

leave a comment »

Case Name and Date Comes From Prevailing Party Majority/Plurality Author Concurrence/Dissent Authors Decision
Williams 9/3/09 COA[1] State Dietzen Unanimous 7-0
Holt 9/3/09 PC[2]1°M State Meyer Page dissents; P. Anderson joins 5-2
Davis 9/10/09 COA State Gildea Page dissents 6-1
Jones 9/10/09 COA State B. Anderson Page dissentsMeyer dissents; P. Anderson joins 4-3
Buckingham 9/10/09 DA[3]1°M State B. Anderson Unanimous 7-0
Doppler 9/10/09 PC1°M State Dietzen P. Anderson concurs in part, dissents in part; Meyer and B. Anderson join 4-3
Martin 10/8/09 DA1°M State Dietzen Page dissents; P. Anderson joins 5-2
Jackson 10/8/09 (co-def Martin) DA1°M State Dietzen Page incorporates Martin dissent; P. Anderson joins 5-2
Johnson 10/8/09 DA1°M State* Magnuson Unanimous 7-0
Rourke 10/22/09 COA State B. Anderson Gildea concurs P. Anderson dissents 5-1^ in final vote 4-2 in opinion
Peck 10/22/09 COA State B. Anderson P. Anderson dissents; Page, Meyer join 4-3
Fardan 10/22/09 DA1° M State (Court vacates surplus convictions) Gildea Page concurs; P. Anderson joins Meyer dissents 6-1 in final vote 4-3 in opinion
Vang 10/29/09 DA PC 1° M State Dietzen Unanimous 7-0
Vang 10/29/09 DA 1° M State Dietzen Unanimous 7-0
Schlienz 11/5/09 COA Dfndt Page Unanimous 7-0
Atkinson 11/5/09 DA1° M State Page Unanimous 7-0
Edwards 11/19/09 COA State Dietzen Page dissents; P. Anderson, Meyer join 4-3
Pearson 11/25/09 DA PC1° M State Meyer Page concurs 7-0 in final vote 6-1 in opinion
Riddley 11/25/09 DA1° M State P. Anderson Unanimous 7-0
Back 12/10/09 COA Dfndt Gildea Unanimous 7-0
Sanders 12/17/09 COA State B. Anderson P. Anderson concursPage dissents; Meyer joins 5-2 in final vote4-3 in opinion
Loving 12/17/09 DA1° M State B. Anderson Unanimous 7-0
Stein 1/07/10 COA State Magnuson P.Anderson concurs; Meyer joinsMeyer concurs; Page, P. Anderson join 6-0** in final vote3-3 in opinion
Walen 1/14/10 PC1° M State P. Anderson Unanimous 7-0
McDaniel 1/21/2010 DA1° M State Magnuson Unanimous 7-0
Fleck 1/21/10 COA State Page Unanimous 7-0
Moua 1/21/10 PC1° M State Gildea Unanimous 7-0
Raleigh 2/4/10 DA1° M State Meyer Unanimous 7-0
Lopez 2/11/10 COA Dfndt Magunson Unanimous 7-0
Tomassoni 2/18/10 DA1° M State Magnuson Unanimous 7-0
Holmes 2/25/10 COA State Dietzen Unanimous 7-0
Lessley 3/11/10 COA (writ prohibition) Defendant P. Anderson Gildea dissents ; Dietzen joins 5-2
Cox 3/18/10 DA1° M Defendant P. Anderson Unanimous 7-0
Matthews 3/18/10 DA1° M State Dietzen Unanimous 7-0
Ferguson 3/25/10 PC1°M Defendant Gildea Unanimous 7-0
Wertheimer 4/22/10 COA Defendant B. Anderson Unanimous 7-0
Carufel 4/29/10 COA State Dietzen P. Anderson concursPage concurs 7-0 in final vote5-2 in opinion
Her 5/6/10 Remand SCOTUS after DA1° M State Gildea Page dissents; P. Anderson joins 5-2
Hannon 5/13/10 PC1°M State P. Anderson Unanimous 7-0
Francis 5/13/10 PC1°M State Dietzen Unanimous 7-0
Jenkins 5/20/10 DA1° M State Page Unanimous 7-0
Stone 6/30/10 COA State B. Anderson Unanimous 7-0
Finnegan 6/30/10 PC1°M State Gildea Meyer dissents ; Page, P. Anderson joinP. Anderson dissents ; Meyer, Page join 4-3
Chavarria-Cruz 6/30/10 COA Defendant Magnuson Gildea concurs ; Dietzen joins 7-0 in final vote 5-2 in opinion
Anderson 6/30/10 DA1° M State B. Anderson Page concurs ; Meyer, P. Anderson joinMeyer concurs ; Page, P. Anderson join 7-0 in final vote4-3 in opinion
Prtine 6/30/10 DA1° M State/Def (remand on issue whether D. consented counsel’s concession guilt) Page Gildea concurs in part, dissents in part; joined by Dietzen; joined in part by P. Anderson 4-3
Staunton DA1° M State B. Anderson Unanimous 7-0

[1] Court of Appeals

[2] Post-Conviction

[3] Direct Appeal

^Page did not take part in case

** Dietzen did not take part

Written by cweissenborn

September 4, 2010 at 3:00 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.